The party line on Richard K. Morgan’s Broken Angels is that it is not as good as Altered Carbon, its predecessor, but it’s still good. I don’t agree. I found the book to be slow moving, dense with infodumps, and pitted with plot holes.
I think Altered Carbon worked because it was a noir mystery at heart, with a Science Fiction sheen that tended to amplify the story and not distract from it. The book moved at a good pace but character development didn’t suffer. The world was carefully revealed through Kovacs’ own ignorance of Earth’s culture and his own struggles to grasp it. The story introduced us to an incredibly interesting dilemma in the romance subplot with Kristin.
Broken Angels tries to succeed without any of the strengths of Altered Carbon. We have an extremely tenuous romantic interest or two. We have a bunch of problems: how can Kovacs, who ranks so highly in his mercenary unit, disappear for so long without being punished? Why does he care so much for his new companions, yet his pack loyalty to the other Wedge soldiers is so easily overcome? How can Kovacs, who should be in trouble, talk back to his commander with such insolence? I am willing to suspend my disbelief enough to allow for Martians, but Kovacs returning after his stint as a reluctant loner P.I. to be a high ranking mercenary is a bit too much to swallow. It’s all possible, but it just doesn’t feel right.
The most promising part of the book is the contact with the remnant Martian culture which is the focus of the plot, and while I don’t mind some things being left uninvestigated (Morgan’s at his best with his throwaway references to the richness of his Universe outside the stories, such as Semertain and Hand’s voodoo religion), I think the book would have been a thousand times more interesting if it had spent a few more pages within the Martian ship instead of on the fucking beach.
Stylistically the book suffers from the plague of having each character speak in the same voice, a problem which happens to China Mieville’s characters as well. This was easily forgiven in Altered Carbon, but it seems that Broken Angels piles on the burly dialog a little too often. I hope the next Kovacs novel finds him a little less of a superman, a little more vulnerable and believable, and hopefully a little more grounded and focused in his story.