Rubbing Bats and Scuffing Balls

June 27th, 2005

TJTodd Jones is having a hell of a season. The journeyman pitcher is now closing for the Florida Marlins and has 13 saves so far. (I bet he was even a free agent in your fantasy baseball league when the season started!)

Jones has written short, honest articles for The Sporting News (they’re also carried on Yahoo) for some time now. The latest, however, is something of a departure, at least in terms of content: it details and defends the widespread cheating that goes on in the game of baseball today.

As long as I’ve been around the game — and as long as there has been baseball — people have bent the rules to gain an advantage.

Not only that, but Jones, who, despite the moustache, comes across as a really nice and upright guy [update: I take this back; see comments], goes on to catalog his own rule-breaking (don’t call it cheating!).

I pitched in Denver for two years, and at a mile above sea level, I used pine tar every time I pitched at home. My thinking was that I was more than 5,000 feet in the air and was entitled to at least do that much. I never thought one thing about it. Was it cheating? My numbers say no, given that my career ERA at Coors Field is 7.64 in 59 games. It’s very dry in Denver, and that makes the baseball slippery. I needed the tar to hold onto the ball. I didn’t want the ball to slip and hit a hitter. At least, that was my thinking. I never considered it cheating; I was breaking even.

I find this fascinating in light of all the hoopla surrounding steroids. If this is really the way the game is, who can blame players for juicing up, despite what the rules say? Baseball’s biggest mistake has been in not drawing a line in the sand; it has a double standard that’s allowed to stick because the team owners and the commissioner have no balls of their own.

3 Responses to “Rubbing Bats and Scuffing Balls”

  1. Jeff Says:

    Jones’ mouth has got him in some pretty hot water in the past:

    http://espn.go.com/mlb/news/2003/0430/1547422.html

    He’s an Alabama guy, so what do you expect?

  2. Justin Says:

    Did he write that before or after the Angels/Nationals flap about Brendan Donnelly using pine tar? And did you see that Yadier Molina was accusing Jason Bay of stealing signs in their game yesterday?

    And get out of 3rd place - that’s supposed to be mine! :)

  3. LTR Says:

    I personally don’t think stealing signs is so wrong — it’s something that both teams have the opportunity to do and doesn’t necessarily give individuals an advantage. I’ll take that back if someone can prove otherwise. :)

    About Jones — thanks for pointing that out, Jeff. He seemed like a nice enough guy, but those comments disgust me, so I will edit my post.

    -LTR, manager of the third-place Tokyo SuperGodzillas!

Leave a Reply