As an antidote to all the 2004 retrospectives, I offer three more or less randomly selected all-time favorite albums of mine.
In the Aeroplane Over the Sea, by Neutral Milk Hotel (1998)
I admit, despite being tuned into the Atlanta music scene of the early 90s due to the influence of my older brother, who was at Emory at the time, that I missed this band from nearby Athens until recently. In fact, I was turned on to NMH and the Decemberists at the same time. The bands are sometimes compared to each other, more for the visions of the songwriters and their taste in instrumentation than for any substantial reason. This album, NMH’s last, is a masterpiece of ecstatic acoustic guitar strumming and grotesque lyrics (see “Two-Headed Boy”). It’s not for everybody, but it’s definitely for me.
Nonsuch, by XTC (1992)
Everyone complains that this album is XTC lite, poppier and less edgy than their early progressive punk stuff. Well, shit. This album is a masterpiece, full of heavenly vocal harmonies, smart lyrics which range from the satiric to the surreal, and great guitar playing. If you have to skip “The Ballad of Peter Pumpkinhead,” do it, and forget about whether or not XTC has gone soft, because Nonsuch runs the gamut from tender to angry and remains beautiful throughout.
The Pros and Cons of Hitchhiking, by Roger Waters (1984)
I know, I know, Roger Waters made Pink Floyd suck. I agree with you. This album won’t change your mind. But somehow it wormed its way into my brain when I was a disaffected teen, before I became the fountain of good cheer you know now, and I still enjoy listening to it when I’m in the mood. This was the direction Pink Floyd was heading in when they were doing The Wall and The Final Cut - a personalized Roger Waters nightmare, full of dangerous women and Germans, and with a total of about four chords. But hey, it’s a deeply introspective album, with sophisticated, darkly surrealistic (if I may use the word again) lyrics. It follows the narrator through a series of nested dreams that take him to a biergarten and to the American West. I think. At the very least, it has Eric Clapton on guitar, a very catchy title track, and a naked lady on the cover.